S’pore Passenger Loses Lawsuit Against PHV Driver Who Braked For Chicken, Ordered To Pay S$15,000
A Singapore woman who sued a private-hire vehicle (PHV) driver after he braked to avoid a chicken crossing the road has lost her case, with the court ordering her to pay S$15,000 in legal costs.
The incident happened along Holland Road on Feb. 19, 2024, when passenger Yvonne Chen Qianyun was travelling in a vehicle driven by Tan Teng Kiat.
According to the court’s judgment on Nov. 18, Tan had applied his brakes after a chicken moved into the path of the vehicle ahead of him. The driver in front had also braked in response to the animal, prompting Tan to slow down to avoid a collision.
Chen subsequently claimed that the braking caused her to suffer personal injuries and filed a negligence claim against Tan.
Passenger Argued Driver Did Not Keep Sufficient Distance
Chen’s case largely centred on whether Tan had maintained an adequate following distance from the vehicle in front.
She argued that the force and manner of his braking were more than what was reasonably necessary to prevent a collision, alleging that the driver had failed to meet the standard of care expected of him.
Tan acknowledged that he owed his passenger a duty of care but maintained that he had sufficient time and distance to react to the situation.
He argued that the braking manoeuvre was a normal response rather than an emergency or excessively forceful stop.
Passenger Initially Wanted To Pursue The Other Driver
The court also considered what Chen had said and done shortly after the incident.
Following the braking incident, she reportedly asked Tan whether he had taken down the licence plate number of the vehicle in front, as she intended to pursue a claim against that driver. She had also asked Tan to act as a witness in the claim before later changing her mind about whom she wanted to take legal action against.
The court further heard that Chen had at least two other pending cases before the District Court, both involving accidents in which she had been passengers.
Judge Dismisses Claim, Says Incident Was Part Of Life
After examining the circumstances, the judge concluded that Tan had done what could reasonably be expected of him when faced with the situation.
The court found that the force and manner of his braking did not exceed what was reasonably necessary to avoid a collision, and that he was therefore not liable for the incident.
Chen’s negligence claim was dismissed, and she was ordered to pay Tan S$15,000 in costs.
The judge acknowledged that Chen was an innocent passenger who had suffered an injury in an incident beyond her control. However, he noted that not every loss suffered in life necessarily gives rise to legal liability.
He described the incident, which was triggered by a chicken crossing the road, as part of the “vicissitudes of life”, noting that some losses must simply lie where they fall.
