A Malaysian podcaster, identified as Sulaikha, has sparked national controversy after claiming that “ancient Malays possessed supernatural abilities, including the power of flight, which they later taught to the Chinese.” The statement, made during a podcast episode, has drawn sharp criticism from historians and academics who caution that such claims could distort public understanding of history.
Historians Slam Claims as Baseless and Illogical
Dr Sahul Hamid, a lecturer at the Faculty of Humanities, Universiti Pendidikan Sultan Idris (UPSI), criticised the remarks as “illogical and unscientific,” stressing that historical research must be based on verifiable evidence rather than myth or fantasy. “History must rely on cross-verified sources. Myths are merely folk tales. If we allow myth-based narratives to circulate unchecked, society’s capacity for rational thinking will erode,” he said.
He further warned that “pseudo-history” built upon fabrications and imagination is highly dangerous. “It not only embarrasses the nation in the eyes of the global academic community but also weakens young people’s ability to think critically,” he added, calling for stronger academic responsibility in public discussions on heritage and identity.
Experts Urge Responsible Discussion of Cultural Heritage
Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka (DBP) chairman Professor Sharil Yahya also weighed in, urging Sulaikha to exercise caution and accuracy when discussing historical topics. He explained that while historical records do show cultural exchanges between the Malay world and Tang dynasty China, the so-called “ability to fly” was likely a misinterpretation of martial arts references.
“The term might refer to the ‘flying kick’ in Malay martial arts, known as pencak silat, rather than literal flight,” Sharil clarified. “I understand her intention to celebrate Malay greatness, but this must be done in a truthful, contextual way—without exaggeration, distortion, or misleading the public.”
The debate has since gone viral on social media, with many Malaysians expressing concern over the rise of unverified historical narratives being presented as fact. Academics have urged content creators to collaborate with experts when discussing history, to prevent misinformation and maintain intellectual credibility in the digital age.